Was ‘Oumuamua a Fragment from a Disintegrated Comet?

May 23, 2019 - Comment

‘Oumuamua’s unusual trajectory again out to interstellar area will be defined if the article was a comet fragment with the density of air. One artist’s impression reveals ʻ1I/’Oumuamua as a cigar-shaped object.ESO / M. Kornmesser ‘1/’Oumuamua, the interstellar thriller object that briefly visited the inside photo voltaic system in 2018, has confirmed a troublesome nut

‘Oumuamua’s unusual trajectory again out to interstellar area will be defined if the article was a comet fragment with the density of air.

Portrayal of 'Oumuamua (1I/2017 U1)

One artist’s impression reveals ʻ1I/’Oumuamua as a cigar-shaped object.
ESO / M. Kornmesser

‘1/’Oumuamua, the interstellar thriller object that briefly visited the inside photo voltaic system in 2018, has confirmed a troublesome nut to crack. Astronomers are nonetheless arguing about what it even is — asteroid, comet, or one thing else altogether? Now, in a pair of research posted just lately on the arXiv (paper 1, paper 2), Zdenek Sekanina (JPL-Caltech) suggests the article is likely to be an ultra-low density fragment from a comet that disintegrated whereas passing close to the Solar.

‘Oumuamua’s Bizarre Exit

Observers didn’t catch ‘Oumuamua till it was already headed out of the photo voltaic system, however intense observing campaigns in October and November of 2017 rapidly pinned down its bizarre orbit. It was clearly hyperbolic, taking the interstellar customer on a one-time tour round our Solar.

Oumuamua painting by Hartmann

One other artist’s idea reveals ‘Oumuamua formed extra like a pancake than a cigar.
© William Okay. Hartmann

Given it is transient go to, we solely know just a little bit about this object: Photometry confirmed that it’s purple, and a lightweight curve confirmed that it is probably tumbling because it goes. However now we have no direct pictures — the article is likely to be cigar-shaped, pancake-shaped . . . or possibly it is an alien gentle sail. (Sure, even that final one is a scientific suggestion, albeit a controversial one!)

The article handed Saturn’s orbit in January, and it’s lengthy been out of vary of even one of the best telescopes, however that does not imply we’re accomplished with it but. Marco Micheli (European Area Company) and colleagues obtained such good measurements of its trajectory out of the inside photo voltaic system that in 2018 they had been in a position to say unequivocally that gravity wasn’t the one pressure guiding its path outward. The outcomes required some type of further pressure — aka, a non-gravitational acceleration — and now it’s as much as theorists to say what that pressure is likely to be.


Here is a 3rd artist’s impression, exhibiting ‘Oumuamua as a comet.
ESA / Hubble / NASA / ESO / M. Kornmesser

If ‘Oumuamua had been a comet, the reply can be apparent: Ices sublimating off the floor because it neared the Solar would have created jets which may have tweaked the article’s trajectory. However right here’s the rub: Observations didn’t discover any indicators of exercise. In actual fact, infrared observations from the Spitzer Area Telescope just about dominated out the discharge of carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide — two compounds generally present in comet tails.

However as a result of different attainable explanations appeared so outlandish, many astronomers continued to cling to the comet state of affairs. In any case, a small quantity of outgassing might need evaded detection. A current paper by Darryl Seligman and Greg Laughlin (each at Yale) urged that the sublimating ices might need been totally water, producing a nozzle-like jet that swung like a pendulum, which made the entire cigar-shaped comet rock in flip.

Ruling Out Outgassing

However there are issues with that rationalization, writes Sekanina.

First, a have a look at comets coming from the photo voltaic system’s Oort Cloud — a spot probably just like the place ‘Oumuamua got here from — reveals that such objects don’t have the quantity of water ice wanted to elucidate ‘Oumuamua’s trajectory. Furthermore, the outgassing that does happen turns these comets into fuzzy dots, in stark distinction to ‘Oumuamua’s star-like look in pictures. Then there’s the truth that lively Oort Cloud comets don’t speed up the way in which ‘Oumuamua did. The nail within the coffin, although, is that water ice — even when current — couldn’t have sublimated rapidly sufficient to spur ‘Oumuamua on its method.

Path of 'Oumuamua

The monitor of our first-known interstellar object, now named ‘Oumuamua, because it handed via the inside photo voltaic system in late 2017.
Brooks Bays / SOEST Publication Providers / Univ. of Hawaii

So if not comet-like exercise, then what drove ‘Oumuamua’s non-gravitational acceleration? The remaining pressure into account is photo voltaic radiation strain. For the Solar’s photons to push ‘Oumuamua quick sufficient to elucidate its acceleration, although, the article itself would have needed to have a density lower than zero.0015 grams per cubic centimeter — successfully gentle as air.

Sekanina has proposed a state of affairs to create such an ultra-low density object: Earlier than we ever noticed ‘Oumuamua, it was a part of an interstellar comet. Because the comet approached our Solar — after billions of years spent touring between stars — it disintegrated. By the point our telescopes picked it up, ‘Oumuamua was a mere fragment left over from an epic journey.

“Shortly after the Micheli et al. paper got here out, someone urged to me that we is likely to be seeing photo voltaic radiation strain,” Grey shares. “I instantly replied, ‘Nah.  Cannot be.  The article must have an absurdly low density for that to work.’”

“However,” he provides, “I believe Sekanina makes a very good case for that to be precisely what we’re seeing right here, together with an evidence of the way you get an object with that low a density.”

“The article by Zdenek Sekanina is definitely intriguing,” says Seligman. He acknowledges Sekanina’s argument that ‘Oumuamua certainly didn’t obtain sufficient vitality from the Solar to energy the outflow of sublimated water molecules. Now, Seligman and Laughlin are exploring another situations, together with the opportunity of a fraction composed primarily of molecular hydrogen ice, a fabric that has been theorized (and even urged as a constituent of darkish matter) however not but noticed. Another choice is that ‘Oumuamua is a so-called fractal mixture, a porous pile of icy mud.

“Both method,” Seligman says, “the ramifications for planet formation are extraordinarily fascinating.”

Supply hyperlink


Comments are disabled for this post.